A Holiday Party With Spec-Fic Characters

For many of us, the time around Christmas and New Year’s is a time to gather with friends and extended family. A time to throw a huge party and enjoy celebrating. If you’ve done it long enough, experience has shown […]
on Dec 29, 2015 · 3 comments

For many of us, the time around Christmas and New Year’s is a time to gather with friends and extended family. A time to throw a huge party and enjoy celebrating.party toast

If you’ve done it long enough, experience has shown you what to expect from certain people. You know…Uncle George, who always brings fruitcake. Cousin Billy, who eats so many sweets you think his teeth may fall out. Grandma Jenny, who always gives everyone the perfect gift.

Who doesn’t love a party?

That got me wondering, “What would a party of fictional characters look like, especially ones from science fiction and fantasy? Who would fall into which category?” Because surely, why wouldn’t they gather for a holiday party every year?

Here’s a glimpse of what might happen at a spec-fic party.

Oversees the dinner preparations: Sam Gamgee

Hogs the champagne: battle among Pippin, Haymitch, and Tony Stark

Forgets to buy gifts and rushes out to do it at the last moment: Barry Allen

Mediates any arguments that break out: Captain America

Arrives to the party three hours late (but is naturally on time): Gandalf

Brings the most expensive gift: Bruce Wayne

Wants to do nothing but eat and play games: Pippin

Secretly drinks all the eggnog: Peter Quill

Goes around humming Jingle Bells all night: Reepicheep

Voted as having the best Christmas costume: Thor

Sits in a corner reading a book: Hermione Granger

Appointed to keep the fire stoked: Groot

Considered the best Santa Claus: Albus Dumbledore

Is the brunt of everyone’s Christmas jokes: Merry (can’t imagine why…)

Is the brunt of everyone’s North Pole jokes: Legolas (can’t imagine why…)

Brings Christmas cookies: Chewbacca

Peeks at all the presents: George and Fred Weasley

Accidentally sets the kitchen on fire: Pippin (with help from Merry)

Makes too many bad jokes: Han Solo

“Ooohhhs” and “aaahhhs” over the decorations and Christmas lights: Lucy Pevensie

Points out the illogical nature of believing in Santa Claus: Spock

Ensures everyone’s drinks are taken care of, coats hung, and presents assembled: Captain America

Fills the role of self-appointed photographer: Colin Creevey

Makes the biggest mess during dinner: Gimli

Shows up in an ugly Christmas sweater: Rocket Raccoon

Brings an annoying cousin: the Pevensie siblings

Vies for all the attention: tie between Tony Stark and Bruce Wayne

Criticizes the decorations, the guests, the gifts, and everything else: Severus Snape

Crashes the party uninvited: Loki

Never smiles at anyone: Katniss Everdeen

Spends the entire party checking phone: Draco Malfoy

Keeps coming and going with no explanation: the Doctor

Spikes the eggnog with too much whisky: Captain James Kirk

Breaks several dishes: Bruce Banner

Shows an obsession with taking selfies: Spiderman

Is the one person everyone wishes would leave: Oliver Queen

Steals all of Santa’s cookies: Eustace Clarence Scrubb

Arrives with uninvited guests: Gandalf

Knows exactly what gifts to get everyone: Peeta Mellark

Brings the infamous fruitcake: Clark Kent

Talk about some wild dynamics. Don’t know about you, but I think that party would be a blast. Until Loki showed up, of course.

Who and what else would you add to the list?

Thinking About Time

Over all what do you think about stories that manipulate time? What are some of the best stories that you’ve read (or written) which depend on the manipulation of time or on a certain time period?
on Dec 28, 2015 · 15 comments

Back_to_the_Future_Day_(22476884795)With 2015 racing to a close, I’ve been thinking about time. Which brought to mind the use of time in speculative fiction. How important is it? How does it function?

Some might automatically think of time travel or time machines. Back To The Future is one of the best known time-travel, and time machine, movies and is getting a lot of attention because it’s celebrating its 30-year anniversary.

Of course, long before that popular movie were the stories by science fiction writers like H. G. Wells and Julian Huxley involving time travel and futuristic imaginings. However, science fiction does not have a monopoly on stories that manipulate time.

J.K. Rowling utilized a type of time travel, introduced in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. The mechanism is an Hour-Reversal Charm, encased in an hourglass and the incident of time travel was critical to the story, but didn’t make up the story in the same way that it did in Back To The Future.

In his recently concluded Bright Empires series, Stephen Lawhead utilized what he called ley lines to allow characters to move from one time period and place to another, though the idea was actually one of traveling from different dimensions rather than back into different times. The stories read much like time travel, though, and the characters could not travel into the future ahead of their own time—an odd sort of rule if the device in question created dimensional travel.

C. S. Lewis used time differently in his Narnia stories. Time was an indicator of the fantasy world he created and operated independently from time in the “real” world. Hence, his characters could experience hours, days, even years in Narnia but return to the real world at precisely the time they left. On the other hand, they could be gone from Narnia for a year, and return to a discover that hundreds of years had passed in the fantasy world.

Lewis never gave an explanation of this, as I recall, other than that time didn’t work the same way in the two worlds. That’s a very “fantasy-ish” device.

Amazing_Stories_1927_08Science fiction involving space travel deals with the passing of time by creating ways characters can move from place to place over incredible distances. New fuels, for instance, allow ships to travel faster than the speed of light. Transporters move molecules from one place to the other in seconds.

These science devices seem to focused on location, but in fact they are solving the problem of time. Unless ships could go faster than the speed of light, for instance, no one would live long enough to move from one planet to another, let alone from one star system to another.

Many speculative stories seemingly ignore time. If they are set in a fantasy world, for instance, time may be significant only because of the history of the place or because of the change of seasons as it passes.

In horror stories, urban fantasy, and the like, time is likely no different than time in the here and now. There is no different history, no manipulation of time.

20000_Nautilus_enginesSteampunk, on the other hand, is tied to a different time:

Steampunk works are often set in an alternative history of the 19th century’s British Victorian era or American “Wild West,” in a post-apocalyptic future during which steam power has maintained mainstream usage, or in a fantasy world that similarly employs steam power. Steampunk may, therefore, be described as neo-Victorian. Steampunk perhaps most recognizably features anachronistic technologies or retro-futuristic inventions as people in the 19th century might have envisioned them (Wikipedia)

In thinking about time in speculative stories, you might also be interested in reading “About Time,” a post from our archives by former regular contributor Yvonne Anderson, that explores a motive behind some time travel stories.

What are some of the best stories that you’ve read (or written) which depend on the manipulation of time or on a certain time period? What device (literary or physical) creates this time bending? Why is altering time such an important element?

Over all what do you think about stories that manipulate time? Give your view in the poll below. You may answer as many of the choices as you want or create another option.

Merry Christmas

For a child will be born to us, a son will be given to us
on Dec 25, 2015 · No comments

Image courtesy of christmas-clipart.com

Image courtesy of christmas-clipart.com


The Spec Faith regular contributors want to wish you a blessed Christmas.

May you enjoy rich times with your family and wonderful worship of Christ, our Savior, Redeemer, and Lord.

The people who walk in darkness
Will see a great light;
Those who live in a dark land,
The light will shine on them.
You shall multiply the nation,
You shall increase their gladness;
They will be glad in Your presence
As with the gladness of harvest,
As men rejoice when they divide the spoil.
For You shall break the yoke of their burden and the staff on their shoulders,
The rod of their oppressor, as at the battle of Midian.
For every boot of the booted warrior in the battle tumult,
And cloak rolled in blood, will be for burning, fuel for the fire.

For a child will be born to us, a son will be given to us;
And the government will rest on His shoulders;
And His name will be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God,
Eternal Father, Prince of Peace.

There will be no end to the increase of His government or of peace,
On the throne of David and over his kingdom,
To establish it and to uphold it with justice and righteousness
From then on and forevermore.
The zeal of the LORD of hosts will accomplish this.
(Isaiah 9:2-7; emphasis added)

A Ghost Story Of Christmas

The ghostly element of A Christmas Carol is powerfully used for the story’s real purpose.
on Dec 23, 2015 · 1 comment

In our culture of Christmas – patched together, hodge-podge, from centuries of celebration – A Christmas Carol holds an honored place, and it well deserves it. Few works of fiction have entered so exuberantly into the holiday, rejoicing in both its spirit and its pleasures. Charles Dickens saw, indeed, no conflict between the two, and as Scrooge’s cold greed and shut-up heart were expressed in his bleak Christmas Eve, so his reformation, the breaking open of his heart, overflowed into festivities on Christmas Day. The transformation of Ebenezer Scrooge is powerful and convincing, but so are Dickens’ descriptions of stuffed goose, pudding, and Norfolk apples.

It is interesting to me that this story – the most classic of all classic Christmas tales – is also a ghost christmas carolstory. The full title is A Christmas Carol In Prose, Being A Ghost Story of Christmas. I would like to examine this element of A Christmas Carol, neatly summed up in that incongruous phrase A Ghost Story of Christmas.

It is important to note, at the outset, that the only real ghost in A Christmas Carol is Jacob Marley. In our day, ‘ghost’ has been narrowed to mean the spirits of dead people that linger in our world, instead of moving on to the next one. In Dickens’ day, ‘ghost’ still had a general meaning of ‘spirit’, and the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Future are just that: spirits. Supernatural, certainly, and alarming perhaps, but not dead.

Jacob Marley was dead – a fact that the story begins with, and emphasizes through four paragraphs. “This must be distinctly understood, or nothing wonderful can come of the story I am going to relate.” Marley was a ghost, but a very particular kind of ghost – even an unusual kind.

A spiritual lawlessness prevails in the idea of ghosts – as if these souls have somehow evaded, or never had, an eternal destiny under the hand of God, as if they have managed to linger on in this world instead of going on to the next one. It is very interesting, then, that Marley’s Ghost clearly gives the impression that he (it?) is under law – a strict law, perhaps, but not a cruel or even unintelligible one.

“It is required of every man,” Marley tells Scrooge, “that the spirit within him should walk abroad among his fellowmen, and travel far and wide; and if that spirit goes not forth in life, it is condemned to do so after death.” Marley’s ghostly wanderings, far from being anarchic, are a judgment, the fulfillment of a law, and are obviously governed. “Nor can I tell you what I would,” he says to Scrooge. “A very little more, is all permitted to me.”

There are other glimpses, aside from this unseen power that requires and condemns and permits, of a larger, ordered spiritual world. When Scrooge pleads for comfort, Marley sadly rebuffs him: “I have none to give. It comes from other regions, Ebenezer Scrooge, and is conveyed by other ministers, to other kinds of men.”

Besides this sense of a justly ruled spiritual realm, in which ghosts like Marley wander in penance rather than rebellion, this ghost story is unusual in that it is not really about ghosts. The visit from Marley is absolutely crucial, and Dickens knows how to work it for thrills and chills: the foreshadowing of the door knocker and the hearse, which Scrooge can just manage to ignore; the inexplicably clanging bells, all through the empty house, and the dragging chains, beginning down in the cellar; the ghost’s “death-cold eyes”, and the awful detail of it removing the bandage around its jaw.

Yet the brief haunting that Scrooge suffers – and he does, indeed, suffer it – is a mercy, and ends with Marley declaring that Scrooge will not see him again. A Christmas Carol is about Ebenezer Scrooge’s salvation – his reclamation, the Ghost of Christmas Past calls it – and Marley’s Ghost simply has the task of getting his attention. The ghostly element of A Christmas Carol is deftly and powerfully used for the story’s real purpose, centered on something infinitely more important and interesting than any ghost – the soul of a living man.

Seeking Peace In A World Of Strife

Conflict is the backbone of any story. Sometimes it involves a desperate quest to save the world. Other times it dives into the murky waters of relationship problems. Even if a story doesn’t contain explosions, high-speed chases, epic battles, or […]
on Dec 22, 2015 · 1 comment

Conflict is the backbone of any story.

Sometimes it involves a desperate quest to save the world. Other times it dives into the murky waters of relationship problems. Even if a story doesn’t contain explosions, high-speed chases, epic battles, or other obvious displays of conflict, it still exhibits conflict on some level.

In fact, the more I read and pay attention to my reactions at certain parts, the more I’ve realized the quieter conflict is actually more compelling. Not the ADD scene where the superhero is simultaneously fighting off a dozen baddies, but the tense pause before you find out someone the hero trusts is actually a spy.

Without conflict, a story is bland, uninspiring, boring. Why is that? Furthermore, what’s the purpose behind the endless highway of problems down which the characters travel?

Stories are supposed to reflect real life. We identify with the characters, we picture the setting, we understand the situation even if we’ve never experienced it ourselves. On the other hand, writers know well that people love to read about things they would hate to endure in real life.

Enter the strife.

Conflict, Conflict Everywhere

With some stories, the string of struggles is as long as a dragon’s tail. Will it never end for the poor characters?

The thing is, this problem manifests in real life, too. Because we live in a world stained by sin, we’ll never fully escape the consequences. Some days, we feel like Draco Malfoy is torturing us or that life resembles the battle at Helm’s Deep—in all the worst ways.

Theoden at Helm's Deep

Preparing for battle

The conflict we read about mirrors the conflict assailing us.

And like the characters in the story, we long for peace. Why? Because we sense the broken nature of the world. We hear about terrorists shooting innocent people or go through a nasty breakup with someone we considered a friend. A corner of us recoils. Everything about the situation feels wrong. Intuitively, we seek peace, veiled though it is by a world of strife.

That’s where the truth of stories rings most potently. At the end of the day, every tale involves a pursuit of peace.

  • Saving Middle-earth from Sauron
  • Destroying the tyranny of the Capital
  • Restoring Narnia from the grasp of the White Witch

All the battles—physical, mental, and emotional—drive toward a single goal. The light at the end of the tunnel. The achievement of peace, however fragile or fleeting. I submit that stories do this because it reflects the eternal truth of our story, of history.

As Jill says in The Last Battle:

“Oh, this is nice. Just walking along like this. I wish there could be more of this sort of adventure. It’s a pity there’s always so much happening in Narnia.”

To which Jewel replies with tales of peaceful times. The picture he paints causes Jill to exclaim:

“Oh, I do hope we can soon settle the Ape and get back to those good, ordinary times. And then I hope they’ll go on forever and ever and ever.”

Books begin with something wrong in need of fixing. Sometimes it’s an internal struggle, sometimes an external conflict. Typically, it’s both. As the story progresses, the characters come closer to overcoming the problem and bringing life into a state of peace.

Many variations exist, but generally speaking, the story concludes with a satisfying resolution. Using Lord of the Rings as an example, Frodo completes the quest, the enemy is vanquished, the hobbits save the Shire, and a time of peace begins.

Conflict may be the fuel in a story’s engine, but the destination is one where the characters have managed to find at least a glimpse of peace in a world of strife.

The True Story of Peace

With Christmas near, we’re more inclined to turn our attention to this stark contrast presented by our world. After all, what represents the core of this peace-amid-strife concept more than God’s intervention in our strife-filled lives to breathe a Word of peace?

The lines from I Heard the Bells on Christmas Day offer a poignant reminder:

And in despair I bowed my head;

“There is no peace on earth,” I said:

“For hate is strong,

And mocks the song

Of peace on earth, good-will to men!”

Then pealed the bells more loud and deep:

“God is not dead; nor doth he sleep!

The Wrong shall fail,

The Right prevail,

With peace on earth, good-will to men!”

This Christmas, instead of dwelling on the external lack of peace surrounding us—terrorist attacks, hospitalized loved ones, the Syrian refugee crisis—we can rest in the peace God grants.

Won for us by the Prince of Peace, who was born in a stable two millennia ago. Whose coming signaled the truth: one day, the strife will end, and there will be peace.

MERRY CHRISTMAS!

The True Story That Reads Like Speculative Fiction

It is Christmas, or nearly so, and naturally my focus turns to the Christmas story. The true, Biblical story. I understand that many people in the world look at the accounts recorded in Luke 1 and 2 and Matthew 1 and 2 as myth. And with good reason. Those passages read like speculative fiction.
on Dec 21, 2015 · 4 comments

Nativity_Scenes004With the newest Star Wars movie just out, many fans of speculative fiction are squeezing in the movie, despite the busy Christmas season. As fun as it is, and as filled with non-Christian (Buddhist?) religious overtones, it’s still speculative. Imaginary creatures and worlds and wars and weapons make for a lot of entertainment.

But it is Christmas, or nearly so, and naturally my focus turns to the Christmas story. The true, Biblical story. I understand that many people in the world look at the accounts recorded in Luke 1 and 2 and Matthew 1 and 2 as myth. And with good reason. Those passages read like speculative fiction.

I suppose a good number of other passages in the Bible also read like speculative literature, but the Christmas story seems to have compacted a number of speculative tropes. There are several angelic visitations, for example. Joseph had a conversation with an angel, and so did Mary. But before them was Zacharias, John the Baptist’s dad, and his encounter with the angel of God in the temple. Most dramatic, and perhaps most well know, was the visitation of the shepherds, first by a single angel, then by “a multitude of the heavenly host.”

Dreams come into play in the Christmas story as well. Joseph’s encounter with the angel was apparently in a dream, but there was a second dream that apparently saved Jesus’s life. When the wisemen snubbed Herod and didn’t return to Jerusalem to tell him where the Christ child was, he sent a military force to kill all the babies, two years old and younger, in the environs of Bethlehem. Jesus would have been swept up in that infanticide, but for Joseph’s dream that he should take his little family and escape to Egypt.

Speaking of wisemen, their part in the Christmas story is also mysteriously speculative. Wisemen is probably a more palatable term than magicians in this day and age, but they were magi—people schooled in reading the heavens as if the story of humankind has been written in the stars. Hence, afar off in their eastern home, they looked into the night sky and saw a star that told them a king was born in Judea.

A_starry_sky_above_Death_ValleyAgain, undoubtedly by way of erasing some of mysterious from the story, songs and paintings and retellings portray this star as particularly bright. But nowhere in Scripture is such an idea presented. In fact, if the star had been bright, it seems likely that many more people, not just the magi, would have found Jesus.

But there’s more amazing things about this star. First, the wisemen didn’t follow it to Jerusalem where they encountered King Herod. They simply saw the star and proceeded to the most logical place where a king would be born—the seat of power of that country. But not finding him there, they left and the star appeared again. Just appeared. One night it wasn’t there, the next it was. And this time it moved at a perceptible rate so they could follow it. And then it stopped. Right over the house where, by this time, Jesus was.

Mysterious? Magical? Miraculous? Whatever you want to call it, it has the ring of speculative fiction.

But that’s not the half of it. Remember those wisemen? When they, in bafflement, prodded King Herod about the newborn king they expected to find in his palace, he turned to the chief priests and scribes who in turn went to Scripture. They quoted to Herod a version of Micah 5:2.

But as for you, Bethlehem Ephrathah,
Too little to be among the clans of Judah,
From you One will go forth for Me to be ruler in Israel.
His goings forth are from long ago,
From the days of eternity.”

Prophecy, then, also played a part in the Christmas story. Specifically the angel who appeared to the nameless shepherds predicted where they could find the Christ Child—in Bethlehem—and under what conditions they’d find him—wrapped in cloths and lying in a feeding trough. As odd as it sounded, those men acted on what they’d been told and went to Bethlehem where they found Jesus just as the angel had said.

Of course, the bulk of prophecy connected to the Christmas story comes from the Old Testament, not the least of which is Isaiah 7:14:

Therefore the Lord Himself will give you a sign: Behold, a virgin will be with child and bear a son, and she will call His name Immanuel.

Virgin. A woman who had not had sex. And she was pregnant.

Of course Zacharias’s wife Elizabeth was barren and she was also pregnant—with John the Baptist, as it turned out.

This impossible pregnancy was the announcement the angel had given Zacharias in the temple—the announcement he didn’t really believe. Consequently the angel gave him a sign, too, to convince him this birth was a miraculous movement of God. Zacharias would not be able to speak until John was born.

Sure enough, when he came out of the temple, he was unable to tell anyone about the message he had received from the angel. But nine months later, when he wrote that his newborn son’s name was John, his tongue was loosed and he could speak again.

A barren woman, pregnant. A virgin, pregnant. A healthy man, mute. These physical impossibilities were perhaps the greatest elements that seemed speculative in the entire story. But there were neighbors and family members and town gossips who witnessed each one.

Undoubtedly a number of people thought Mary was simply a sinner who had engaged in premarital sex, possibly with Joseph, but perhaps with some mysterious lover they didn’t know about. So they could explain away the impossibility of Jesus’s conception by their own imagination and suspicions.

But what were they to do about Elizabeth? Or Zacharias? How many years had they lived as a childless couple? Long enough to provoke his own doubt. And there was no hiding Zacharias’s inability to speak. As the priest he was to come out of the temple and bless the people. But he couldn’t do it. His public incapacity to speak was not something he could hide. Nor was the immediate restoration of his speech.

wonderful-words-of-life-119318-mThere’s more: Simeon, speaking prophecy over baby Jesus when his parents brought Him to be circumcised. John the Baptist, yet unnamed, jumping in his mother’s womb at the sound of the just-pregnant Mary’s voice. Elizabeth, blessing Mary because she “believed that there would be a fulfillment of what had been spoken to her by the Lord,” though apparently Mary had yet to tell Elizabeth about the angel and his message.

Yep, speculative fiction, for sure. Except for one key point which has to do with God and His nature. The angel said it to Mary:

For nothing will be impossible with God. (Luke 1:37)

If nothing is impossible with God, then all the mysterious, “magical,” miraculous events were His doing, and they really happened. The story might read like speculative fiction, but it is far better because it is true.

Wishing you all a Merry Christmas!

SpecFaith Movie Missions: Return Of The Jedi

The Emperor’s greater evil, Jedi points of view, slave Leia’s scanty attire, Force magic, and final battles—let’s explore them all.
on Dec 18, 2015 · 2 comments

Explore SpecFaith Movie Missions for Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back.

Happy Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens Day!

Will you see Episode VII? If so, how? Are you a longtime Star Wars fan? Or like me, a casual fan who wishes he had been introduced to the Star Wars universe far earlier?

Last week for Christ and Pop Culture Magazine, I shared my story about getting into Star Wars later in life.

That piece released for free viewing yesterday as “Star Wars Episode IV: A New Fan.” Here’s how it starts:

The first time I watched Star Wars—that is, Episode IV: A New Hope—I got in big trouble.

Actually, I only saw half the film with my brother. He got in half the trouble. After all, he was first to confess that we had found the VHS copy of A New Hope in the closet and watched it without permission. It was one of the Mystery Videos inherited from a late grandparent—not official releases but TDK tapes recorded from network TV. We watched it only from Death Star infiltration to the end credits, and it bugged my brother’s conscience first.

I don’t even recall our ages then. I do recall that was a long and difficult two solid weeks with “no electronics,” that is, TV or Computer Time.

But I also recall that feeling of seeing not just something forbidden, but something new and amazing. I had never seen a motion picture like it. (Perhaps you haven’t either. After all, this version was years before the first Special Edition of Star Wars.) Action! Grown-ups, stylized realism, comical robots, bantering humans, chases, effects, spaceships! And Darth Vader, right there onscreen, after all we had heard about him. Wow!

Naturally the “cover-up” made me spend the next several years curious about Star Wars, prequels and all. But I did not actually see the complete film or the full original trilogy until 2008. My girlfriend at the time (now my wife) insisted on my education.

But I did not really become a fan until 2013, when my wife and I re-viewed the films twice.

I finally became not just a Star Wars “appreciator” but a fandom convert. This time, I can even join the rest of the fandom getting hyped for Episode VII.

At the same time, I retain an outsider’s perspective on Star Wars. I can’t help but see and analyze the film differently than fans who have seen the story more than three times.

Star Wars Episode VI: Return of the Jedi, Luke Skywalker and Darth Vader

(Insert Darth Vader dad joke.)

I wonder how much this outsider’s perspective comes through in the below study-group-style questions for the (chronologically) very last Star Wars episode?1

"Star Wars Episode VI: Return of the Jedi": The Emperor

We are never given the Emperor’s tragic story.

  1. Higher evil. Once again we see the story turn toward showing that Darth Vader, as bad as he is, is only a servant of the more-wicked Emperor. What can be true about showing a greater evil behind the evil? And what can also be false about showing this in a story?
  2. Den of squalor. As with the Mos Eisley cantina in Star Wars, what do you think about Jabba the Hutt’s nasty dwellings? How does the story show the bloated alien gangster’s treatment of others, slaves and especially women? Does it approve this behavior?
  3. Liberated Leia. When Jabba enslaves her, she’s shown in this (in)famous skimpy outfit. Some have even called this costume “liberating” for women. What do you think of that response? Can all or some Biblical Christians see such visuals and not personally sin?
  4. Fight for freedom. For the first time since Star Wars, Luke, Leia, Han Solo, Chewbacca and the droids all fight together. How do their interactions now compare with before?
  5. “From a certain point of view.” Ghost-Kenobi says this explains how he could say that Darth Vader killed Luke’s father, instead of being his father. “Luke, you’re going to find that many of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view,” he goes on. Discerning based on Scripture, what may be true about this? What may be false?
  6. “Bury your feelings deep down, Luke.” What do you think about this Jedi philosophy?
  7. “Use your divine influence …” In the Ewoks’ home, C-3PO says they believe he’s a god. Ah, so there are gods in the Star Wars universe? What do you think of this development?
  8. “Use your magic.” Then Luke uses his own. So The Force is Or is it? Thoughts?
  9. “There is good in him. … I can turn him back to the good side.” Is Luke right? Later he surrenders himself to his enemies. Why? What’s changed since Empire Strikes Back?
  10. "Star Wars Episode VI: Return of the Jedi": The Emperor tortures Luke SkywalkerThe Emperor claims to have set this trap all along. How does this make the story better?
  11. “Strike me down with all your hatred.” What is the Emperor trying to do to Luke? Later Luke does defend himself against Darth Vader’s assault. Is there any difference?
  12. Feelings for a girl spur Luke to fight more, but not a love interest. How is this unique?
  13. Why does Luke finally refuse to give in to the Dark Side? And though we don’t see Darth Vader’s face (or until the Blu-Ray version, hear him speak), why does he at last decide to save his son and instead turn on the Emperor? By the story’s end, is Vader a villain, a hero, an “antihero,” or another kind of character entirely? How do we finally see him?

Explore SpecFaith Movie Missions for Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back.

  1. The questions were originally written for a small group of friends at my local church, who viewed and discussed the original Star Wars trilogy over the summer of 2013.

SpecFaith Movie Missions: The Empire Strikes Back

I’m a “Star Wars” newbie and I still find Luke’s loss to Darth Vader one of the most gripping film scenes I’ve ever seen.
on Dec 17, 2015 · 2 comments

Luke Skywalker confronts Darth Vader in the climax of "Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back."

Explore SpecFaith Movie Missions for Star Wars and Return of the Jedi.

Last night with my wife I re-viewed Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back.1 This was only my fourth time seeing it — yes, in my lifetime — which gives me a slight advantage.

Whereas some if not most of Star Wars fans may occasionally wonder if they overvalue the original films based partly on nostalgia, as a newcomer to the saga I might help confirm something for you.

No, your fandom is not based primarily on nostalgia. Yes, the original trilogy really is that awesome.

And yes, Empire in particular is an absolute masterpiece. Once Luke Skywalker experiences his first real battle with Darth Vader, the film gets even better, with stellar and rightly iconic cinematography as well as top storytelling.

This time I particularly noticed Luke’s response when he learns the shocking truth from Darth Vader. I think familiarity and repeat viewings may have dulled the startling nature of how this is shown. Internet memes and parodies also make the scene into a perennial joke, perhaps based partly on Luke’s bizarre facial contortions.

But isn’t that what makes this moment all the more shocking? Luke has just lost this huge battle, lost his hand, lost all his young Jedi dignity and bravado, lost any illusions about Darth Vader being pure evil, and heard the shocking news.2 And if the film were made today, even a great actor might struggle to show all this crashing in at once. I’m not knocking today’s actors, only saying that the scene would be shot and directed differently. Luke’s grief and despair and horror would be much more stylized.

Mark Hamill seems to have chosen differently. For his fantastic performance he seems to realize that Luke could not have stylized or restrained responses.3 He should have a complete breakdown of emotion leading to utter misery and despair. His grimacing face should scrunch into unsightly creases while his mouth twists open in a scream. (If this were done in anime there would be a little bubble coming out his nose, and it would not be funny at all.)

For this fourth viewing, and as a Star Wars newbie who first saw the original trilogy in 2008, I still find this one of the most gripping film scenes I’ve ever seen.

Now for the exploration questions for all of The Empire Strikes Back.

Imperial walkers attack the Rebel base in "The Empire Strikes Back"

  1. If you can recall when you first saw the sequel to Star Wars, what was it like?
  2. Three years later. Much has changed since the last Star Wars Does that leave you wondering what we missed? How does what we don’t see strengthen the story?
  3. Ghost guidance. Obi-Wan Kenobi, previously only a voice (possibly a memory) from the first Star Wars, now upgrades to visual appearances and new directives. If this were to happen in the real world, we would say he was a “ghost” or worse. In Scripture we find warnings against seeking special knowledge through fortunes or from the dead (as in Deut. 18, where God says He speaks only through His priests and His final Prophet, Christ). Knowing this, how should we view guidance from ghosts in this faraway galaxy?
  4. Learning and wartime. Star Wars shows its first ground conflict as Imperial Walkers and troops storm the Hoth rebel base. X-wings fly, soldiers shoot, explosions explode. With war in the news even more recently, due to the potential Syria conflict, how do you react to onscreen wars? What are risks in seeing them? Can they be helpful?
  5. Down to Dagobah. Following ghost-Kenobi’s instructions, Luke arrives on the swamp planet and meets Yoda, and here The Force philosophy occupies much of the story. Any more thoughts on this impersonal, mystical “magic” in the Star Wars world? Good/bad?
  6. "Luminous beings are we, not this crude matter."

    “Purveyors of space-Gnosticism we are, yes, yes, hrm-hrm!”

    “Size matters not.” Yoda goes on to say, “Judge me by my size, do you?” Specifically in the perspective of the story, why is it important that Yoda isn’t a strong huge warrior?

  7. “Crude matter.” Yoda says, “Luminous beings are we, not this crude matter.” Thoughts?
  8. Enter the Emperor. Darth Vader, a prime villain (along with Grand Moff Tarkin) in Star Wars, is seen here answering to another evil, apparently a greater. How may this change how we see Darth Vader, who in Star Wars seemed more like a simple, total-evil villain?
  9. “What know you of ready?” Yoda goes on to say, “Adventure, heh, excitement, heh — a Jedi craves not these things. You are reckless.” Why does he warn against this attitude?
  10. “Beware of the dark side.” Bad character qualities make up the dark side, Yoda says. He also says it’s not stronger than (presumably) the “light side,” but that it is “quicker, easier, more seductive.” Why is Luke curious about the dark side? What do we see later?
  11. “I know.” Han Solo famously gives this reply after Leia says, “I love you.” What does this show about his character? What do you think of Han’s actions and changes in this story?
  12. “No, I am your father.” After Luke’s training and recklessness, why is this so shocking?

Explore SpecFaith Movie Missions for Star Wars and Return of the Jedi.

  1. I wrote these discussion questions in 2013 as part of a series of film viewings and discussions at my church.
  2. Yes, something in me wants to preserve the spoiler, even now.
  3. Indeed, Luke’s continuing reaction after being rescued is more restrained.

The Heavens Declare

“The heavens declare the glory of God; the skies proclaim the work of His hands.” Ps. 19:1
on Dec 16, 2015 · 4 comments

Last Monday, the SyFy channel premiered a new TV show called The Expanse, based on the book series of the same name. I haven’t read the books but I was intrigued by the pilot episoc09b551e-0245-43d9-b9ad-7d35b08e9482.png.watermarkde and I will give it a go, especially since December and January are the wasteland months of cable TV.

I’ve always been a fan of serious sci-fi, particularly the more contemplative works by authors such as Isaac Asimov and Arthur C. Clarke. I enjoy the hardware-heavy action bonanzas of Robert Heinlein or the fantasy/religious/mystical/what-the-heck-did-I-just-read epic tomes of Dan Simmons, but there’s always been something about the cold metal ship drifting between stars that has always held a romantic appeal for me. Movies about tiny humans navigating the unfathomable distances of space, such as 2001: A Space Odyssey, Sunshine, and the parts of Interstellar that didn’t make me gag on my popcorn spark the fires of my imagination even though many consider them to be boring, pretentious, and over-serious.

Perhaps the reason for this appeal is because of the relatively realistic depictions of space travel that these books and movies explore. No glitz and glamor, no whiz-bang weaponry, no baritone space Nazi warlords. Just fragile little people terrified to death of the vast emptiness of space. It’s easy to imagine how such a journey would drive anyone to the brink of madness, if not over it. If you were on a spaceship that was traveling at 99% light speed, the backdrop of stars wouldn’t change for years. YEARS. You would be an infinitesimal particle in an endless void heading towards a giant black curtain with pinpricks of light showing through. Nothing would tell you that you were moving unless you turned the ship at a different angle (just like the moon follows you when you drive at night, the stars would follow you as you sped through space).

It’s in a place like this that a person could plumb the deepest depths of their soul and come face-to-face with their own insignificance and mortality. Here on Earth, we have no idea what this is like. We have friends and family available at the touch of a button. We post a selfie and get fifty “likes” by the end of the day. We are constantly reaffirmed as having value and effect on people around us. But out there, in the silent darkness, we are literally nothing. A mote of dust floating between continents.

As has happstars-06ened numerous times on the page and on the screen, people have confronted their place in the universe and been utterly broken. I think that would be a perfect moment to truly examine what one believes. Ultimately, it comes down to faith.

I’m sure you’ve seen the video going around on social media that keeps zooming in on a photograph of the stars. Each tiny section that is enlarged shows more and more stars, and it is a staggering sight. How could so many stars be crammed into such a seemingly small space? And then you realize that there are TRILLIONS of miles in between even the closest stars. I feel like a YA fangirl because I. Literally. Can’t. Even.

An atheist looks at this and marvels how such magnificence could come about by a chance explosion of proto-physical particles. A theist looks at this and marvels at their particular god’s infinite power to create something so magnificent. There is scientific evidence for both views but in the end, it’s a matter of faith. For me, as a believer in Christ, a journey through space would force me to painfully contemplate my own inevitable end and my corrupt nature, but it would also be a time of supreme worship for the Creator of the vast cosmic ocean in which I was suspended. Pslams 19:1 says, “The heavens declare the glory of God; the skies proclaim the work of His hands.”

When I watch these programs and read these books and imagine that I am on these ships, believing that there is a God who rules over the universe would be the only thing that would keep me from losing my mind. Out there in the cold black void, there is not madness; there is majesty.

Me, A Hero?

Ever wanted to save the city you love? Or be part of a legendary group of heroes who protect (or avenge) the world? Chances are, you’re not alone. What Makes a Hero? In today’s entertainment culture saturated with Marvel superheroes, […]
on Dec 15, 2015 · 6 comments

Ever wanted to save the city you love?

Or be part of a legendary group of heroes who protect (or avenge) the world?

Chances are, you’re not alone.

What Makes a Hero?

In today’s entertainment culture saturated with Marvel superheroes, teenage girls saving their worlds, and powerful characters defeating equally powerful adversaries, it’s easy to develop a skewed concept of what a hero is.

What pictures come to mind?

  • Superman hovering in the air, his cape billowing behind him?
  • Katniss as she refuses to admit defeat and struggles against the Capital with every ounce of strength remaining?
  • Barry Allen zipping through Central City, putting the baddies away and using his spectacular speed to save people?

Heroes, yes, but they only reveal one side of the coin. What do we find when we flip the coin over?

The Ordinary Hero

Image from lotr.wikia.com

Image from lotr.wikia.com

This is the unassuming, not-hero-material hero. Look at Sam Gamgee. An ordinary hobbit whose claims to fame were gardening and serving Master Frodo. In fantasy, you have plenty of examples of the farmboy whose naivety and inexperience outweigh any impressive heroic qualities.

Last time I checked, I’m not an Asgardian god who wields a magical hammer. Pretty sure you’re not, either. (If you are, send me an email. I’d love to get your autograph.) We identify with the lowly characters because they remind us of ourselves.

The more we can relate to them, the more real they become and the more we care about them. Which probably explains the phenomenon of farm boys becoming heroes (but that’s a topic for another time).

Wok Dinners and Heroes

This random quote popped into my head one day and I wrote it down:

One hot summer night, I decided to be a hero. I started by cutting vegetables for a wok dinner.

That seed of a story idea hasn’t gone anywhere to this point, but it illustrates an important point easily lost amid the noise of modern entertainment.

Heroism isn’t a lofty goal attainable only by a select few—the summit of a mountain we could never hope to climb.

You don’t need a cape, a brilliant mind, or staggering powers to be a hero. Neither do you need a vicious foe, an impossible quest, or thousands of lives at stake.

What does this have to do with wok dinners? The reason I included it is that the character saw heroism in the simple task of making dinner. Nothing world-shaking or newsworthy.

That’s the point. We don’t consider ourselves heroes for a number of reasons, but chief among them is the assumption we’re not in any situations where we could be heroic. There’s no dragon threatening to burn down our town, no grand quest overthrow the evil lord.

Chances to be heroic might come, but they’re the exception, not the rule.

Unless you shift your perspective.

Think Small, Not Big

Sam didn’t do anything extraordinary—except for sticking by a friend’s side through a trial. His loyalty and love shine out through his actions. His heroism stems from the hundreds of inconsequential things he did for Frodo.

In a similar fashion, maybe we can comfort a hurting friend or support someone through a rough patch in life.

You can’t go around saving lives like Captain America? No worries. People surround us every day who could use a boost or a friendly ear to hear their troubles.

I’m not saying all this to be legalistic and point out all the ways you’re failing at life.

  • “Shame on me, I didn’t take time to notice this problem.”
  • “I could have been a better sibling.”
  • “Why did I let my temper ruin that situation?”

Not at all. What I am saying is this: oftentimes, being a hero isn’t about the big things.

Yes You, a Hero

What makes a hero isn’t power, prestige, a worthy adversary, a world to save. It’s the willingness to sacrifice for someone else, to put the needs of others before your own. Maybe it involves a journey akin to the quest to Mount Doom.

Or maybe it’s as simple as seeing every part of life as an opportunity.

Look around. There are plenty of ways to be a hero. You never know when an act of kindness, encouraging email, or small gesture of assistance—like making dinner—will have a huge impact, a heroic impact, on those around you.