Will Fiction Last Forever? Part 5

In the New Earth, as here in the Old, we won’t worship things, but worship Christ *with* things. Those may include our speculative stories, maybe even resurrected from this world. Four more reasons why this speculation is based on Scriptural promises about the After-world.
on Dec 8, 2011 · No comments

Whump. Just like that, my car had a new cute little dimple, right in its front bumper.

Its old front Texas license plate — the only remaining outward sign that this vehicle was a foreign import, and not of this world — was now crunched. And in the moments that followed, in the cold and drizzling rain, while a friendly police officer took my and the other driver’s information, I as a citizen of this old world had at least four options:

  1. Swear, pound the wheel, later pound other things in my imagination, and rail against the universe, which is really a rail against its Creator, for this misfortune. This was my car, after all — even if I sort of inherited it from my Texan wife — and the universe (read: its Creator) had no right to do that to my stuff.
  2. Peacefully acknowledge that in the grand scheme of things, this car really did not matter. It belongs to God, and in the end its parts are destined to burn anyway.
  3. After initial sin, and repentance, thank God that I’m perfectly fine, and no one got hurt, and that the car took it on the chin. Meanwhile, this car is God’s car, not my own; I’m only its steward. It is indeed only a God-given thing, to be used for His glory. My wife and I began reading The Fellowship of the Ring in this car. On the way to our honeymoon. So if those memories, or anything else, involving this car would remind me of Him — as an act of Christ-worship — nothing would keep Him from resurrecting it, even a dented-up Mercury Sable, on the New Earth.
  4. Take solace in the fact that material objects can be used for good or evil, such as cars, money, or creative works such as stories — and then, if God removes them or decides never having them is best for us, resenting Him for that divine choice. If you really loved me, Jesus, you’d let me keep that Thing. Yes, I know you could bring it back later, to glorify Yourself, but I “don’t! care! how — I want it nowww.”

Worship with things, not of things

As you may have guessed, I had a hard time writing number 4. Not only does it violate Scripture, of course, it just doesn’t make sense. That’s because materialism ultimately makes no sense. God owns everything. This is His world, where He keeps His stuff.

Those who believe that Things, such as human creations like stories, will last beyond this world — based on their New-Earth study, or even extra-Biblical speculation about the After-world — will find no greater justification for selfish materialism than they would find with another view that is similar to “let’s just leave all those topics alone.”

That’s not to say that pondering the New Earth will resolve all materialism. Of course it won’t. After all, following the car crash, I went through option 1 almost verbatim, before arriving (mostly!) at option 3. Sin came up from within and whispered, Hey, that’s your car, and you don’t deserve this wrong. In this life I doubt we’ll ever defeat all temptations to think of Things as our own stuff, not God’s (they’re not even “on loan” from Him!).

So how to fight materialism, specifically in regards to the stories we love. Might we love them too much? In one respect, yes, but if we mean “love” by God’s definition — His love, through which we can love great stories only because they remind us of Him — that is an impossible question. One cannot righteously “love” anything too much.

It seems that we have two possible solutions to keeping our story-love in perspective:

  1. Enjoy stories, but think that there’s no need to ask if they’ll last beyond this life.
  2. Enjoy stories, and recognize that if God wants to preserve them forever, He will.

Differences between these views — based on the broader underlying beliefs — has led to some friendly disagreements throughout this series! In my view, though, either set of beliefs is vulnerable to being hijacked by materialism.

For no. 1, materialism could take this guise: stories won’t really matter in eternity, so make sure you get what you can in this life.

For no. 2, materialism could sneak in this way: if material things and creations are good, then hang onto them as much as you can — God would never take them from you!

Either way, sin never creeps in unless it has some existing truth to twist. And any truth can be twisted into some kind of sin, such as materialism — whether the goodness of stories, the love of God, the wrath of God, the need to study apologetics, the need to feed or care for the poor, the need to warn against materialism, or the need to study what Scripture has clearly promised us about the New Heavens and New Earth.

If someone sins while studying those particular Biblical truths, and basing speculations upon them, the sin is not in the studying, or even the speculating. Similarly, readers here may know that one cannot rightly or reasonably blame speculative stories just because someone else wrongly used them to justify “escapism” or other wrong beliefs.

God’s Word, and truth, do not cause sinful behavior. Nor does anyone’s sin, or potential sin, mean we must ignore what it says about a particular topic.

Rather, sin abuses truth to justify materialism, or asceticism, or whatever.

Those are sins we must avoid. Yet as we’re doing that, we also worship God, in this Old Earth, in many different ways — and one of those ways is our speculative stories.

Will this form of worship expire in the New Earth?

Nothing in Scripture suggests it will, and in fact many texts endorse ancient and modern things, such as ships, trade, precious metals, trees and nature, continuing as means by which we enjoy and worship (they are the same task!) our wonderful Savior.

Last week, I overviewed four reasons to support eternal stories, based on Scripture — most in the Old Testament — and suggested further reading. Now let’s go forward, and also finish this series. Why else we can anticipate that our good God, if He wanted, could preserve stories for His glory?

Fifth: because our God is a God not of eternal annihilation, especially of good things that would continue to honor Him, but of resurrection.

5. God is a God of resurrection.

  1. Christ died. His body, the same one in which He died, rose again. That means that actual atoms, DNA, cells, torn muscles and skin (save for a few exceptions, in His hands, feet, and side!), whisked back together, repaired, reversed their decay. Maybe they were supplemented — not 100 percent replaced! — with new material or powers. Then in that body, He departed the tomb. He visited others. He walked, ate, and drank. Later, he ascended. And He is still in that resurrected body. “There is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus” (2 Tim. 2:5). Note the present tense: is. He is still a Man, still flesh and blood — not the corrupt “flesh and blood” (an idiom for fallen flesh) in 1 Cor. 15:50  that can’t inherit the Kingdom, but an imperishable, redeemed flesh and blood.
  2. Perhaps the most beautiful image of resurrection in all of the Old Testament.

    We will die (barring Christ’s return first). Our souls will then be present with the Lord (2 Cor. 5:8), for a temporary separation. Though we’ll be joyful, we’ll also await being “further clothed” (2 Cor. 5:4) with an immortal body, a “spiritual body” (1 Cor. 15:44), supernatural, powered by the Spirit. At that resurrection, will all those bodily components — molecules, cells, skin particles — be pulled up in supernaturally flown streams from the earth, to reassemble? We don’t know, but we do know that there will be some kind of continuity. The old body died, like a seed in the ground. The old body was mortal, perishable. From it will come the new body, immortal, imperishable, and of the Spirit. “Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God,” Paul says (1 Cor. 15:50, then clarifies with a parallel: “nor does the perishable inherit the imperishable.” Corrupt, perishable flesh and blood will become imperishable, redeemed flesh and blood.

  3. Creation will die. At present it’s groaning (Romans 8: 18-25), and waiting “with eager longing” for God’s people to be revealed, in hope “that the creation itself will be set free from its bondage to corruption and obtain the freedom of the glory of the children of God” (verse 21). (Note the contradiction to annihilation or replacement!) The “creation itself,” this same planet, will first die (2 Peter 3:10), then be resurrected. Very much like Christ. And very much like us.

If we in our resurrected bodies will not only worship Christ in some vague fashion, that is, a “beatific vision” of only gazing at His face in wonder or singing, but also in “earthly” things like trade, farming, or other jobs (as in Isaiah 60) — we find even more support for anticipating newer and even better stories in the After-world, alongside the ones we now enjoy in our worship of Christ.

6. “Resting” from real-world wonders on New Earth to enjoy stories would be little different from resting to enjoy Scripture.

Now comes some of the practical questions, based in resurrection truth, but also based in some extra-Biblical speculation. The first of these goes something like this:

Why would we want to stay inside all day, reading stories, when there’s an amazing world to explore and other things to do in our worship of Christ?

The same question could be asked about Scripture itself, the Word that God has clearly promised to preserve forever (as discussed in part 3). Why would we want to read that? I suggest: for the same reason we want to read the Old Testament now. Yes, that first Covenant is fulfilled, but we still find new truths, embedded in its words, which we had not seen before. It also reminds us of what wonders God did. The fact that He works wonders in the present doesn’t (or shouldn’t!) make us bored with Him in the past.

Thus, surely we’ll find time in New Earth for varying levels and forms of worship. One day, or over several hours, we might design a building, or feast with friends, or go on some incredible journey, in worship. Then another day, or another series of hours, we might “rest” (though it’s all a rest!) and relax. We might read His Word. Or another great story, about our present world, or imagined worlds, or Old-Earth battles and victories.

Let’s get more specific. Imagine the most vivid, fantastic, yet Biblically allowed picture of New Earth you can imagine. I’m talking here new creatures, exciting missions, and uncharted frontiers on other planets or galaxies. Now, is there no possible way that God, our infinite God, could create even more wonders beyond our wildest imaginations?

We’ll keep trying to imagine what He could come up with next. He’ll keep blowing us away. And for eons upon eons, in the redeemed universe with its capital planet, we’ll keep worshiping Him for it, even as we reflect His role as Creator in our subcreations.

7. If we assume any evil echoes or reminders couldn’t belong in eternity, that would also apply to the Bible.

Stories require conflict. The New Earth won’t have any. How would stories even work?

First, I’d question that New Earth will have no conflict, that is, disagreement. What we know it won’t have is sin that results from it. For example, author Randy Alcorn offers:

Because we’re finite and unique and because we’ll never know everything, we may not agree about everything in Heaven. […] Some of us will have insights others don’t. Some will have a  better understanding in one area, others in a different area. Our beliefs can be accurate but incomplete, since we’ll not be omniscient. […] C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, and other friends in their group called The Inklings often argued ideas with each other. […] Could they even say, “Let’s think and talk to the King, approach an angel or two, bounce our ideas off Paul, Luther, and Augustine, and then meet again and share what we’ve learned”?

[…] Even though Christ’s insights would be absolutely accurate, that doesn’t mean we’ll always fully understand them. God has made us learners. That’s part of being finite.

From Heaven, pages 348-349

That will make things interesting — and delightful! Even now, though, we might picture some of what that could be like, because in Christ, Christians can have disagreements about issues, and lovingly agree to disagree, and mean it.

So what about our stories? Those would seem to require antagonists who don’t disagree agreeably, at least, so we think, from our limited Old-Earth perspective. But could some genius author create a new genre that doesn’t require traditional villains or opposing causes, which is still just as entertaining and honoring to the God who had long since defeated all real-life villains? With renewed minds, could we more easily appreciate a story for its Christ-exalting truths and beauties, even without action, conflict, or battles?

That was my secondary argument, put first. My primary reminder is that, again, we’ll have God’s Word on the New Earth — a Word that not only reminds us how we got there, but of sin, violence, or untruth. Therefore, one can’t consistently claim that even Old-Earth-style stories that do have evil elements would automatically make us sin. The Bible won’t do that, and we know it will last forever. And again, we also know that Scripture, and manmade stories with evil reminders, don’t even always make us sin here. How much more, in that redeemed universe, will we see the sin in glorious God-given perspective, recalling what it was like, and praise God for His deliverance?

8. Imagine the possibilities.

Now comes the end of this series, and this column (which I admit is extended-length, due to the Christmas season and other ideas, coming up!).

I’m curious about your thoughts throughout; your beliefs, past and present, about the After-world; and your hopes for how we may honor and praise our perfect, magnificent Savior after He brings His New Heavens to New Earth, to dwell with mankind (Rev. 21).

With what speculative stories do you worship Christ now?

Which speculative stories would you love Him to resurrect, if He chooses?

What kinds of worshipful stories do you imagine we might create on New Earth?

Knowing that could happen, what would you change about those stories now?

Knowing what He has promised in the New Earth, how might that change our lives on this old one? How does it change our stories? Do we cling to them as if Things are all we want, or as if we’ll only get them in this world? Or do we hope to see them in eternal perspective, trying to be Heaven-and-New-Earth-minded so we’re of earthly good?

Soli Deo Gloria!

E. Stephen Burnett explores fantastical stories for God’s glory as publisher of Lorehaven.com and its weekly Fantastical Truth podcast. He coauthored The Pop Culture Parent and creates other resources for fans and families, serving with his wife, Lacy, in their central Texas church. Stephen's first novel, a science-fiction adventure, launches in 2025 from Enclave Publishing.
  1. Galadriel says:

    There’s so much worth reflecting on here…but I really should be working on homework. Note to self: reply later. For now, I want to say that it’s so easy to turn towards response one. Especially if the thing is  something you really need–cell phone, computer….

  2. Paul Lee says:

    I’m curious about your thoughts throughout; your beliefs, past and present, about the After-world; and your hopes for how we may honor and praise our perfect, magnificent Savior after He brings His New Heavens to New Earth, to dwell with mankind (Rev. 21).

    I think of speculative stories as vague expressions of truths that are invisible but real to us in this form of existence.  I speculate that in the ultimate Heaven (and hell) these once-invisible truths will be manifest as literal realities.  For instance, I think the chaos of rebellion against God’s Law is ultimately manifested as physical, eternal flames in Hell.  Likewise, I speculate that all the invisible truths about redemption and unimaginable wonder will become literally real in Heaven.  I don’t think we will be able to create anything over and above that.  In fact, I think each of us might see our deepest longings and inspirations take on material form.
    But that’s just a thought.  Mr. Burnett’s speculation sounds very reasonable and compelling, too.  I still like mine a little better, though. 😉

    There’s so much worth reflecting on here…but I really should be working on homework.

    Me, too!  Bye.

    • I speculate that in the ultimate Heaven (and hell) these once-invisible truths will be manifest as literal realities. […] I speculate that all the invisible truths about redemption and unimaginable wonder will become literally real in Heaven.

      Definitely I’d agree. But would God do everything all at once?

      Surely He would keep things getting better and better, more incredible, more fantastic, in all our futures — leaving us plenty to speculate about in our stories in the present. …


  3. I never thought about enjoying and worshipping being the same thing. That’s an interesting thought. I know the catechism says man’s chief end is to glorify God and *enjoy Him* forever, but I didn’t equate that with worship. I do believe that everything we do unto God, even the most menial task, becomes an act of worship! That being said, though, I think there is a difference between enjoying a “thing” and worshipping its Creator. The two can go hand in hand, certainly. But if enjoying “things” can be worship, “worship” could be downgraded to a mere happy feeling completely unrelated to God. And that destroys the meaning of the word, in my humble opinion. Thoughts?

    “I’m curious about your thoughts throughout; your beliefs, past and present, about the After-world; and your hopes for how we may honor and praise our perfect, magnificent Savior after He brings His New Heavens to New Earth, to dwell with mankind (Rev. 21).”

    Wow, this could be long…here goes! 😀

    I firmly believe that the After-world will be as “real” and physical as our world today, and I think we will eat, drink, fellowship, live in houses, create art of all kinds, build things, explore the world/universe, etc. just as we do now, but without sin (how glorious that thought!). I think we will become the people God meant us to be, unhampered by any of the old sin or the struggles of this fallen world. And all throughout we will have perfect, constant communion with God, and be able to fellowship with our Savior in the flesh. And I love your point that we will continue learning!

    I, for one, love the thought that – with all the “time” of eternity! – we might be able to meet, talk to, and really get to know ALL of God’s people from all of history, even on a personal level. That idea is so amazing to me!

    On the more speculative end of things, and regarding fiction – I actually don’t usually imagine myself writing fiction in heaven. Not knowing and only able to imagine, I tend to speculate on the “safe” side and imagine that I will move on to one of my other writing habits: hymns and worship music. That’s something I *know* I can glorify God with in the New Creation! But if there IS fiction in eternity, I would probably continue crafting stories, too. 🙂 I’m not much concerned about it, knowing that whatever God has planned will be utterly incredible and will completely blow our minds!

    This is maybe a little off topic, but my favorite description of the coming of the New Heavens and Earth came about during a Bible study with some friends; we were talking about the glorious union of Christ and the glorified church when my sister-in-law suddenly lit up with excitement and burst out, “It will be like the most epic wedding party EVER!!” Ever since then, that’s kind of what I’ve imagined – a huge, joyous wedding reception. 🙂 After all, human marriage is supposed to be a picture of our spiritual union with Christ! And of course, after the initial joy of the wedding itself, the bride and groom embark on a lifetime of growing closer and getting to know one another better. Further up and further in!

    In Him,
    Bethany J.

    P.S. I really hope to explore this topic a bit on my own blog soon!

    • I never thought about enjoying and worshipping being the same thing. That’s an interesting thought. I know the catechism says man’s chief end is to glorify God and *enjoy Him* forever, but I didn’t equate that with worship.

      Bethany: perhaps tomorrow I’ll have more thoughts in response to your responses, but for now (and with The Two Towers paused in the other room) I might suggest: put Desiring God by John Piper on your Christmas wish list. 😀 He delves into the whole “worship as enjoyment” concept, not just as a System based on the Westminster confession, but as a crucial element of Scripture’s “plot” and how we interact with God. In worshiping Him, we enjoy Him, and vice-versa.

      Piper has more popularly termed this “Christian Hedonism,” that is, living to get more of God Himself, and making that our greatest pursuit. While some may not like the term, I’m okay with it, and its hyperbole gets folks thinking — and even better, checking further into it! And to me, all this is “historically” one and the same issue. It was the same year that I read Heaven that I read Desiring God. The former is more specific; the latter is more general, and even more directly applicable now.

      I can also heartily recommend Desiring God’s website. All their resources, and even many of their books — including Desiring God itself — are free online.

      Back later …

  4. Martin LaBar says:

    As always, thanks for your work!

What do you think?