A Christian media leader is again warning about stories with fictional magic.

Todd Friel, host of the “Wretched” radio and TV series, made the comments in this Facebook promo video on Dec. 13. A fuller video is here.

At Speculative Faith, we believe Christian fans of fantasy need to consider these issues. When Christians voice their concerns or uncertainty about fantasy, we can’t simply say “that’s legalism.” We also can’t just say “that reminds me of what my parents or that one pastor did,” and then reject it.

After all, what hard truths might we miss, if we ourselves act so legalistically against unfamiliar or annoying ideas?

But even if we understand these issues better, we need to know what beliefs other Christians have been taught about fantasy. After all, the Christian missionary would need to understand his non-Christian neighbors’ culture so she can better share the Gospel with them. Likewise, we need to understand our Christian neighbors’ culture–including videos like this one–so we can better share in the Gospel with them.

That’s why we encourage you to watch the whole video. Then consider your own response based on Scripture, not just as a fantasy-genre fan/defender or “geek,” but as a person who wants to glorify Jesus in everything you do.

In this case, we would say that Friel means well, just as many Christians do who raise concerns about fictional magic.

However, Friel’s chief oversight is this: He commits a category error. He’s ignoring the very real difference between real occult practices, which do exist and which God does forbid, and the kind of pure-imagination fictional magic that does not and cannot exist in the real world.

For instance, he suggests two initial responses to “wizard fiction.” To paraphrase Friel’s paraphrases:

1. What’s the big deal? It’s Just Fiction.
2. Well, but there’s good magic and bad magic in fiction, and you can just sort of tell the difference.

Friel tries to handle the second response thoughtfully, though he concedes he does not quite understand it. (This is usually the sort of thing Christians say when they want to defend at least The Chronicles of Narnia or The Lord of the Rings and are using anything they can get.)

However, we would disagree with the wording of both of these notions.

The first is too flippant about the fact that Jesus wants every child of His to transform their thinking about everything to be like His. Fiction is never “just fiction.” In fact, this sort of statement devalues or even insults fiction. Stories are part of human creativity, which is a gift of God, and therefore becomes dangerous in sinful hands.

The second is a poorly stated adaptation of our real reasoning: not that there is “good magic” and “bad magic” in fiction, but that there is real occult “magic” (divination, idolatry, manipulation) versus made-up, imaginary, reality-impossible “magic” that does not exist. And discerning readers who approach entertainment–or rather, human recreation–with intention to glorify God, according to the Bible, can sort out the differences.

Our own Rebecca LuElla Miller wrote a response to the Wretched video on Facebook:

Wretched, you asked, Should we watch/read wizarding fiction? There are so many points to make here.

1. There is a difference between pretend and real, and much “wizarding fiction” is pretend. Do those engaged in the witchcraft of the Bible wave magic wands or fly on broomsticks? No, because those things aren’t real. Never have been. We as believers need to discern what is real and what is pretend, and we ought not spend great efforts to fight the pretend. As someone on another site mentioned, it’s likely that in your own apple scene, the one who “hates” apples, probably doesn’t. Was he lying or pretending?

2. Stories, even fantasies, are vehicles that can teach the truth. The stories are not the issue. There are even fantasies in Scripture. For example King Joash told King Amaziah a short fantasy about talking trees and thorn bushes getting married, recorded in both 2 Kings 14 and 2 Chronicles 25. Judges 9 records another when Jotham told a story that involved talking trees when he prophesied to the men of Shechem. Stories that encourage involvement in evil, including divination and talking with the dead and the actual practices of real people that practice witchcraft, should be treated differently than those that teach life lessons through the pretend.

3. God created our imagination, and there is nothing wrong with inventing tales and heroes and places that by their existence point to what God in Christ has made available to us. That’s what the Narnia books do. Yes, there are witches and other evils in those books, just as there is Satan and other evils in the Bible. The presence of evil does not disqualify a book from being worthwhile, valuable even. I could go on, but I think those three points more than out weigh the ones you addressed in the video.

Furthermore, a Christian leader simply cannot engage the topic of fantasy fiction accurately or biblically, unless he or she first explores, and understands, a more biblical view of the purpose of stories in the first place. I e-cycled this comment from Christians, Please Stop Warning Against Human Popular Culture Until You Know What It’s For:

Why not frame this topic in a biblical worldview, rather than use the world’s language?

Why not discuss popular culture—human stories and songs—in terms of human creativity being a gift from God? The way some pastors talk, popular culture is some alien (even if “harmless”) thing unrelated to God. But if God gives this gift (of popular culture-creation), then He, not us, defines the terms of how the gift is best used—to glorify Him, to guard against idolatry, and to make sure we get the most joy out of using the gift in the ways He has prescribed.

Why not explore how Jesus has built the work-rest rhythm into the universe, starting right in Genesis 1? Why not consider how stories and songs are part of being human, whether they’re shared around a campfire or enacted on your tablet screen? Why not allow the possibility that Scripture seems to allow—that we will create cultural works in eternity?

I would even go so far as to suggest that if the Christian leader cannot allude to the biblical view of recreation, or articulate this view in his body of work somewhere, he probably ought not talk about culture or popular culture at all.

You can consider more thoughts on how to respond When Pastors Criticize Popular Culture. About Deuteronomy 18 witchcraft, including a ground-level exploration of the text itself and what it means, see Deuteronomy 18 Witchcraft: What It Is and Isn’t.