Lorehaven
  • FREE SUBSCRIPTION: download every issue
  • Find the best Christian fantastic novels
  • Join book clubs and connect with other fans
NEW: Order print issues online!
Advertise Seek Review Library Add a Novel Feedback
Library

Find Christian fantastical novels

fantasy | sci-fi | supernatural and beyond
All novels Search Add a novel
Fate of the Redeemed, Chad Pettit
Valor's Worth, Rebecca P. Minor
Heartmender, V. Romas Burton
Sorrowfish, Anne C. Miles
Babel, Brennan S. McPherson
The Story Raider, Lindsay A. Franklin
Remnant, Daniel Peyton
Light from Distant Stars, Shawn Smucker
Beatitudes and Woes, editor: Travis Perry
Shard & Shield, Laura VanArendonk Baugh
Jordan's World, Allen Steadham
2085: The Rise and Fall of The Sisters, Christopher J. Weeks
Wilding, L. A. Smith
The Treasure of Capric, Brandon M. Wilborn
Daily Articles

Daily articles from SpecFaith

latest articles | archives | statement of faith
News tips Suggestions

Evil Is a Dangerous Beauty
| Brandon M. Wilborn, Dec 13

How to Face the Devil in Combat, Part 1
| Travis Perry, Dec 12

What Was God Thinking?
| Mark Carver, Dec 11

The Impossible That God Alone Can Do
| Rebecca LuElla Miller, Dec 9

Reviews

Find fantastical Christian reviews

All reviews Request a review Share review

Frozen II: They Tried
| Shannon McDermott, Dec 4

‘The Tick’ Season 2 Points Viewers Toward Truth, Love, and Freedom
| Adam Graham, Sep 17

‘Joshua’ Offers Readers a Strange, Unbiblical Alt-Version of Jesus
| Audie Thacker, Sep 10

‘Warm Bodies’ Portrays a Vivid Yet Grotesque Gospel Image
| Marian Jacobs, Jul 12

Other Worlds

Find more from Christian creators

E. Stephen Burnett

Cover Reveal for The Pop Culture Parent: Helping Kids Engage Their World for Christ
| E. Stephen Burnett, Dec 6

Pssst: Christian Endorsers of Bad Books May Not Have Even Read Them
| E. Stephen Burnett, Oct 18

Commenter on Sexual-Revolutionary Allies: ‘They’re Enablers, Not Friends’
| E. Stephen Burnett, Oct 14

It’s Legalistic to Punish Joshua Harris for the Sins of ‘The Purity Culture’
| E. Stephen Burnett, Jul 29

Lorehaven
Magazines
Lorehaven Library
Speculative Faith
E. Stephen Burnett
Lorehaven serves Christian fans by finding biblical truth in fantastic stories. Book clubs, free webzines, and a web-based community offer flash reviews, articles, and news about Christian fantasy, science fiction, and other fantastical genres.
Gift Guide Subscribe to Lorehaven
/ / Articles
Rebecca LuElla Miller
Website |
Best known for her aspirations as an epic fantasy author, Becky is the sole remaining founding member of Speculative Faith. Besides contributing weekly articles here, she blogs Monday through Friday at A Christian Worldview of Fiction. She works as a freelance writer and editor and posts writing tips as well as information about her editing services at Rewrite, Reword, Rework.

Find similar articles

  • Art And The Clive Staples Award, ContinuedArt And The Clive Staples Award, Continued
  • The Fine Line Between Reality and FantasyThe Fine Line Between Reality and Fantasy
  • The Characters We LoveThe Characters We Love

Explore more

Topics:
C. S. Lewis Characters J. K. Rowling J. R. R. Tolkien
Names:
characters contentment Dobby Reepicheep Sam Gamgee Thanksgiving Day

Thankful Characters

Despite privation, death, dangers, and concerns for the future, the settlers found reason to rejoice. They exhibited a degree of contentment, a gratitude for what they had rather than resentment for what they had lost.
Rebecca LuElla Miller | Nov 25, 2013 | No comments |

Thanksgiving-BrownscombeAs Thanksgiving Day approaches here in the US, I’m mindful of the basis of our holiday. Primarily it was instituted in various settlements in the 1600s as a day to remember the ways in which God provided. Secondarily, it (or they, since there was no one set date in those early years) was a day of celebration for the harvest.

In 1621 in the settlement at Plymouth, 58 colonists hosted 90 members of the Wampanoag tribe because, by teaching them food growing and gathering skills and by donating food supplies for the winter, these native Americans were instrumental in helping the colony survive. Consequently, many see Thanksgiving as a day to express gratitude to significant friends, family, and neighbors.

The thing that impresses me about these early celebrations is the fact that they took place even though the overall picture of these colonies was quite bleak. Many people died because of disease. Supplies through the winter were meager, at best, and more people died of starvation. In addition, an attack by the Powhatan Confederacy in 1622 wiped out a number of smaller settlements and killed twenty-five percent of the Jamestown population.

assorted pumpkins-1433668-mNevertheless, the colonists, in what would later become the Commonwealth of Virginia, held any number of Thanksgiving observances. Yes, despite privation, death, dangers, and the concerns for the future, they found reason to rejoice. They exhibited a degree of contentment, a gratitude for what they had rather than resentment for what they had lost.

When I think of stories, however, no matter what the genre, I think of a main character who is not content. He is missing something he wants, something he needs, in order to fix a problem that has cropped up in his world. Consequently, I don’t often think of fictitious characters as being content or thankful.

Until I considered minor characters. Those who are a part of the story but who are not the central figures, may indeed exhibit thankful hearts.

Think, for example, of Gimli, the dwarf in The Fellowship of the Ring who was one of the company traveling with Frodo Baggins. He stands out in contrast to the stereotype of dwarfs as greedy and disgruntled.

First he was grateful for the opportunity of traveling into the mines of Moria and learning what happened to his kin who had sought to reestablish a community there. Second, he was ever afterward thankful for having met Galadriel, the elfin queen of Lothlórien. Later he expressed sincere happiness as a result of his friendship with Legolas.

Sam Gamgee is another Tolkien character who is a good example of one who is gratefulr. In the Shire he was thankful to be Mr. Frodo’s gardener. On the way to Rivendell, he was content to see elves, and could have died happy after that first encounter. Most of all, however, he was satisfied to walk into danger beside Frodo, to carry his burden, and in the end, to carry his friend, no matter how bleak the circumstances.

In the third volume of The Chronicles of Narnia, C.S. Lewis also created a notable character who demonstrated gratefulness: Reepicheep. He was happy to be a Talking Mouse, and became content even without his tail. Mostly he was content with his lot–being the one who would go on a quest to the end of the world, though it meant he would leave all he loved.

Dobby2In the Harry Potter series, J. K. Rowling created perhaps the best grateful character of all: the house elf, Dobby. In Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Harry Potter ends up freeing Dobby from his servitude to the Malfoy family. From that point on, Dobby is so grateful to Harry Potter that he will do whatever he can to help or protect Harry Potter, even put his own life at risk.

What are some other notable characters who exhibit thankfulness? What do you think fuels these characters to be so grateful, even when their outer circumstances may not seem to warrant that attitude? For writers, do you have a grateful character in your story? For what is he or she so thankful and why? In the end, how do we as real people stack up against Reepicheep or Sam Gamgee or Dobby? Is it possible to be as sold-out grateful as these characters were?

Rebecca LuElla Miller
Best known for her aspirations as an epic fantasy author, Becky is the sole remaining founding member of Speculative Faith. Besides contributing weekly articles here, she blogs Monday through Friday at A Christian Worldview of Fiction. She works as a freelance writer and editor and posts writing tips as well as information about her editing services at Rewrite, Reword, Rework.
Website |
  • Tweet
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Print
  • Pocket
  • WhatsApp
  • The Characters We LoveThe Characters We Love
  • Memorable FathersMemorable Fathers
  • Thanksgiving--An American HolidayThanksgiving--An American Holiday
  • Everyone Needs A Sam GamgeeEveryone Needs A Sam Gamgee

Leave a Reply

Connect with
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
avatar
Pleased to meet you.
Help fans find you.
Just in case you subscribe to anything.
Connect with
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
avatar
Pleased to meet you.
Help fans find you.
Just in case you subscribe to anything.
  Subscribe  
Notify of
Julie D
Guest
Julie D

Interesting. I haven’t thought of that much.

Vote Up0Vote Down  Reply
6 years ago
Rebecca LuElla Miller
Author
Rebecca LuElla Miller

Thanks for your feedback, Julie. Glad to know this article gave you something more to cogitate. 😉

Becky

Vote Up0Vote Down  Reply
6 years ago
Leah Burchfiel
Member
Leah Burchfiel

[Much tangenting within]
On the flip side, thankfulness is one of those things that are better off welling naturally rather than being mandated. It’s one of those things that can be used to dismiss people and/or “keep them in their place.” Like slaves being told to be happy that they have masters who give them the bare minimum of food, clothing, and shelter and don’t beat them often. That thing about Sam Gamgee being happy to be Frodo’s gardener had me wondering if anybody had done a Marxist reading of LOTR, because there are distinct marks of classism in it (not to mention racism and sexism, but there are other vantage points for those). Which I guess is to be expected, since medieval Europe and Middle Earth carry a lot in common.
And then I started started on a long, long tangent about George MacDonald and classism (he was a man of his Victorian time), but then I deleted it and figured I probably just need to write some reviews on MacDonald’s work where I parse through all the Victorianisms and their conflation with virtue and/or religion. That might be too academic for submission to this site, but maybe that’s a sign that I need to start my own inconsistently updated blog of reviews among all the thousands of other inconsistently updated blogs of reviews on the Internet.

Vote Up0Vote Down  Reply
6 years ago
Rebecca LuElla Miller
Author
Rebecca LuElla Miller

Continued from earlier comment:

About Sam Gamgee being happy as a gardener, I’ll admit, it gets my hackles up when someone suggests that no one could be happy “just being a gardener.” We have discredited manual labor so much in our day, I think it’s shameful. God made us to work, and in fact, before sin entered the world, He gave Adam the job of being a gardener.

If you remember the last book of Tolkien’s trilogy, it was Sam who saved the Shire by using the gift Galadriel had given him to re-grow all the trees that Saruman and his minions had destroyed. It’s a high calling, as high as any other, and I dare say Tolkien would have viewed it as considerably higher than a good many desk jobs our current culture esteems.

But about deleting your thoughts on George MacDonald, notleia, pleas don’t feel like you have to censor yourself on our behalf. If you write something more scholarly than most comments, we aren’t going to take away your Spec Faith visitors card. 😉 And I don’t think anyone is sitting back rating comments. (This one’s got the humor of comic books–an 8.2. This one’s run of the mill–5.0.) Seriously, I hope you always feel free to share your thoughts.

Becky

Vote Up0Vote Down  Reply
6 years ago
Paul Lee
Member
Paul Lee

That might be too academic for submission to this site, but maybe that’s a sign that I need to start my own inconsistently updated blog of reviews among all the thousands of other inconsistently updated blogs of reviews on the Internet.

Go for it. I’d read about Victorian classism in the context of George MacDonald.

Reviewing/criticizing stuff is frustrating, because you are never able to express all the thoughts you had on the piece the way you wanted to, and it always takes longer than it feels like it should. And it’s usually pretty thankless. Still, it feels good to have said something real about a work, and to have contributed to the Internet’s junkyard. 😉

Vote Up0Vote Down  Reply
6 years ago
Rebecca LuElla Miller
Author
Rebecca LuElla Miller

No question, notleia, that a thankful heart cannot be mandated. I’ve never thought that’s what Thanksgiving was. Never heard of slaves being told they had to be thankful for what their masters gave them, though I don’t doubt that could have happened. Rather, as I read about the history of Thanksgiving Day, it seemed to grow from all these local communities holding a day of thanks celebration in a rather chaotic manner–some years having one, some years not, never on the same day or at the same time as a neighboring community. I think as the nation began to form a more cohesive national identity, the push began for a national day. President Lincoln saw it as a way of bringing unity, and established the national day right in the middle of the Civil War.

To be continued

Vote Up0Vote Down  Reply
6 years ago
HG Ferguson
Guest
HG Ferguson

Ah, dear Sam. Happy with his own little garden, not a garden “swollen to a realm. His own hands to use, not the hands of others to command.” Thanks for reminding us of these truths, to be, like Paul, autarkes — “content” — not allowing anything to get between us and our Maker. The essence of sin is, after all, to hanker after “more” and no matter how we can get “it” — thank you so much for turning our hearts back to God’s Truth!

Vote Up0Vote Down  Reply
6 years ago
  • FREE SUBSCRIPTION: download every issue
  • Find the best Christian fantastic novels
  • Join book clubs and connect with other fans
NEW: Order print issues online!
Advertise Seek Review Library Add a Novel Feedback

Daily articles from SpecFaith

latest articles | archives | statement of faith
News tips Suggestions

Evil Is a Dangerous Beauty
| Brandon M. Wilborn, Dec 13

How to Face the Devil in Combat, Part 1
| Travis Perry, Dec 12

What Was God Thinking?
| Mark Carver, Dec 11

The Impossible That God Alone Can Do
| Rebecca LuElla Miller, Dec 9