1. COMMENT: AUTHOR: Jeff Draper DATE: 12/5/2008 3:55:00 AM

    Amazing, Star Wars had pretty much the same effect on me. 

     

    —– COMMENT: AUTHOR: Rebecca LuElla Miller DATE: 12/5/2008 6:43:30 PM

    Jeff, that’s cool! It had a powerful effect on me, too. I generally say that Lewis and Tolkien and Stephen Donaldson had the biggest influence on my writing, but I didn’t really become a fantasy writer until after Star Wars. The world was so real, the conflict so important. It brought back all that I’d felt when I’d read those great novels.

    Anyway, be sure to catch part two of Dean’s article.

    Becky

     

    —– COMMENT: AUTHOR: DB Ellis DATE: 12/11/2008 6:47:29 PM

    As an kid I was in love with star wars (I was 6 when the first one came out and its among the first few movies I ever saw).

    As I’ve grown older, though, I’ve found so much in it that I just find…..disturbing.

    Among the worst is the fact the droids R2D2 and C3PO are sentient beings bought and sold (and even having their memories wiped) by the people who are supposed to be the “good guys”.

    Its slavery, pure and simple, and the films never treat it as if it was in any way problematic. Nor do any other star wars fans when I bring the subject up to them.

    The droids are depicted as being untroubled by their slavery (so long as they have a “good” master—none of them want to be owned by Jabba the Hut) and so, apparently, nearly all of the audience for the films casually accepts it as OK as well.

    That’s troubled me for a long time. One of the interesting things about works of fiction is that the audience doesn’t just suspend disbelief…..it often suspects its system of values as well.

    More and more I find myself on guard as to what unstated and often unnoticed messages a work of fiction is getting under our guard.

     

    —– COMMENT: AUTHOR: Rebecca LuElla Miller DATE: 12/13/2008 9:04:13 PM

    Wow, DB, I totally missed that one. I saw the movie first when I was much younger, too, but still an adult. I never moved past the idea that they were machines, but you make an important point as to their sentience.

    More and more I find myself on guard as to what unstated and often unnoticed messages a work of fiction is getting under our guard.

    Great point! My soapbox comes out with the discussion of reading with discernment. It seems to be the philosophers and theologians who realize the power of story to affect thinking. The rest of us need to catch up and read a lot more critically, I think.

    More and more I’m thankful for the teachers I had who worked to make us think.

    Becky —–

What do you think?